May 9, 1996 saw yet another incident involving low-head dams, this one being compounded by a lack of  safety gear. Two kayakers planned a late afternoon run of Big Eagle Creek on the West side of Indianapolis, IN. The river, which was running high after recent rains, is flat except for a low-head dam near the

The pair reached the dam at around 5:50 p.m. Hickham ran first. He broached in the hydraulic, flipped, and was caught in the hydraulic. His companion cut to one side to avoid hitting his friend and was pushed on through. As Hickham surfaced, he shouted for his friend to retrieve his kayak, then suddenly disappeared. Resurfacing, he shouted for help before going under for the last time. His partner tried to paddle upstream to help him, but fortunately for the partner, the current prevented him from doing so.

His partner remained for ten minutes, searching for his partner. When Hickham could not be found he landed his boat and called police. The initial search for the victim was unsuccessful. The next day the gates of an upstream dam were closed but still Hickham could not be found. His boat and paddle were recovered quickly, but the body was not recovered until ten days later, some distance downstream.

SOURCE: Jordan Ross and Bill Lawless, Hoosier Canoe Club; Indiana DER Boating Accident Report

ANALYSIS (Walbridge): While dams are deadly, they are also capricious, they may catch one person, then let the next one through. In this case, survival was due to sheer luck. The man who came through was a first timer, while his friend was supposedly experienced. The lack of PFD’s and helmets makes us inclined to doubt the experience claim, however.