Re: Minimum safety gear
Posted by:
rob (IP Logged)
Date: November 21, 2007 02:25PM
Well, at this point I've got to comment . . . The topic of this thread and the content of this thread area really hitting a bit of a divergence. And, it is probably the stated topic which is perhaps slightly 'ill-chosen'. Strictly speaking, for a great many boaters and outings, "Minimum safety gear" could hardly include all the things being suggested!
In the original post it was offered "Is there a difference in what a kayaker, a canoer and a raft should have on board at all times?" Obviously that would be true. (For rafters, at least framed or large rafts, 'flip lines' are MANDATORY safety gear, but ridiculous for all others.) More to the point, "Minimum safety gear" would vary far more depending upon WHERE and WHEN you are boating. How difficult a river, how remote a river, how long a river, under what water/weather conditions, . . .
"Minimum safety gear" for a summer outing on an in town park-and-play wave with the river running at 'normal' flows will obviously be quite different that for a cold weather/water, multi-day, exploratory expedition on a remote river with the possibility of rapidly changing flows. For the former, I might choose and need no more than an air matttress or inner tube and sneakers. If it's shallow I may wish to add knee pads, elbow pads, maybe shin guards, and a helmet. If there's more current and deeper water (and even if not) it may be best (though not mandatory in most states, since my 'craft' is not a 'boat') to have a PFD. Et cetera, et cetera.
"Minimum safety gear" is always 'something less than you have with you' if nothing goes awry. It is only 'something more than you have with you' if something goes awry and you are not successful in being able to deal with it.
So, the answers will range (relatively speaking) all over the place because the "Minimum safety gear" depends on so many other factors. You really have to look at each outing, each situation, and consider "What is the WORST FEASIBLE FORSEEALBE SITUATION" that could happen (with your group, your various craft, the river, the weather, ...), and if you are prepared for that, you have the "Minimum safety gear". If something 'unforseeable' happens, your "Minimum safety gear" may or may not be enough.