Close call on the Russell Fork
by "Honorary Kayaker" (Jim Michaud)
posted to rec.boats.paddle
Date: 1999/10/05

On Saturday, October 2, I was at the Russell Fork for the first release of the year.  I was expecting it to be another wonderful ho-hum day on the river but it turned out to be anything but.  I scouted the first major rapid (Tower) and ran it cleanly with my open canoe.  The next rapid to be run was Fist.

Fist is just a straight shot down the left but not so far left that you go under a 55 foot long boulder that's supposed to be undercut.  In the past I've seen scores of boaters bounce off the side of the boulder and never saw any of them come anywhere close to going under it.  Hell, I paddled the Lower Meadow just the day before and had a great run.  The Lower Meadow is the most undercut river that I've ever heard of so to me the boulder to the left of Fist was just another undercut.

I started my run with the intention of staying dry instead of going through the meat of the wave-hole close to Fist rock in the middle of the river.  I went way left and when I got to the bottom wave I kicked my canoe facing more left so that I would glance off of the wave and stay dry.  The move worked perfectly except that my canoe bumped against the face of the 55 foot long boulder.  No big deal.  I just leaned hard against the rock with my hand with the intention of pushing myself around to the side of the rock.  I 've done it many, many times.  Very suddenly the entire 13 foot canoe went straight down with great speed as if being sucked by a giant vacuum cleaner. I remember starting to jump out of the canoe and the next thing that I remember is that I was floating on my back in pitch-blackness with the
bottom of a boulder in my face.  I felt some slow moving current moving me along the rock head first so I started clawing at the ceiling, pulling myself along faster.  I also started to mentally talk to myself, giving myself instructions and encouragement.

"I'm NOT going to drown!  I'm going to get myself out from under here."

I kept pulling and clawing my way for what seemed like an eternity.  My lungs were hurting bad.  I opened my mouth to take a breath of air and took in a little water instead.

"Dummy!  You're going to drown that way.  Keep your mouth shut no matter how much your lungs hurt.  Keep pulling!"

I thought that there might be an air chamber down there but gave that up as a hopeless fantasy.  My only hope was to keep clawing my way out.

"The current seems to be going very slow.  It's really black in here.  Keep your mouth shut.  Keep pulling.  Doesn't this rock ever end?"

More clawing.

"Oh, my lungs hurt soooo much.  I don't think that I'm going to make it...I REFUSE to drown!  Keep your mouth shut.  Pull! Pull faster!"

More clawing.  Finally I reached for another hunk of the ceiling and my right arm shot straight up.  An air pocket?  No.  I cocked my head back andsaw a little light.  I'M OUT!!

A breath of air never felt so good!  I swam to shore and walked downstream until I could see a guy standing on the big flat rock just below Fist.  I gave him a double thumbs up with both of my arms extended over my head.  I then walked farther downstream until my friends at the top of the rapid could see me and I sat down for a little breather.

I looked at my helmet and life jacket.  The helmet had several new nicks and gouges and the top back of the life jacket was very dirty and scuffed up like it was dragged.  This had to have happened while I was being sucked under the boulder but I have no recollection of it.  I wonder if I was knocked out.

I waited on top of the boulder until the water dropped.  My friends walked back along the railroad tracks and managed to pull the canoe out.  We tied it to a tree and walked out in the dark.

The next morning I walked in before the release with a bunch of tape, rope and a sharp knife.  I made a temporary repair with the tape and a stick then paddled out before the release arrived.  I made past El Horrendo before the release arrived which was good because below there it was easier to paddle the river with full flow even with a battered canoe.

In the morning the river was only running 80 cfs so before paddling downstream I quickly checked out the undercut.  The undercut is really a dome-shaped tunnel that goes from one end of the boulder to the other.  A very large slab of rock blocks most of the entrance of the tunnel.  The opening into the tunnel is therefore rather small; enough to fit a person and a small kayak but not enough to fit a large canoe.  The opening is the only way that water enters into the tunnel so this causes a great suction due to the venturi effect.  The side of the boulder rests on the ground so it blocks water from entering from the fast moving rapid.  This is good in as far as if boaters hit the side of the boulder they don't have to worry about going under it.  Just stay away from the front of the boulder.  Since almost all of the water comes in only through the relatively small opening the water under the boulder is more like a slow moving eddy.  If I didn't claw my way along the ceiling I know that I would never have made it through.

Directly above where the tunnel exits there's a plaque dedicated to Munn who drowned under the boulder in April of 1995.

There are old boaters and there are bold boaters but there are no old, bold boaters.  I always felt that I was an exception to the rule because at the age of 61 I usually manage to hold my own on class 5 rivers.  After this episode I plan on being a little more careful about my boating and strive to be just a plain old boater.

I haven't slept very well the past few nights.

Jim Michaud

PS. Jim now says "And I'll never run the left side of Fist again!"

Click here to go back to the Russell Fork
Click here to go back to the American Whitewater Rivers Pages
Click here for Doug Arrington's Step-by-Step of the Major Rapids!
go(); $cpage->stop(); ?>